Choosing the right car insurance company is crucial for financial security and peace of mind. After evaluating over 50 auto insurers, NerdWallet has released its list of the best car insurance companies of 2025, based on affordability, customer satisfaction, coverage options, and financial strength.

Top 5 Car Insurance Companies of 2025

Here are the leading auto insurers across various categories, along with their average rates and key highlights.

1. Travelers – Best Overall Car Insurance Company

  • Full coverage (annual): $1,722
  • Full coverage (monthly): $144
  • Minimum coverage (monthly): $45

Why It’s the Best:
Travelers earns the top spot for its well-rounded offerings, including standard coverage options plus add-ons like new car replacement and gap insurance. It also provides extensive discounts, making it a solid choice for most drivers.

2. Auto-Owners – Best for Affordable Rates

  • Full coverage (annual): $1,868
  • Full coverage (monthly): $156
  • Minimum coverage (monthly): $37

Why It’s the Best:
Auto-Owners offers the lowest minimum coverage rates among the top insurers. It provides a variety of coverage options and bundling discounts for those looking to combine multiple policies.

3. State Farm – Best for Digital Experience

  • Full coverage (annual): $2,286
  • Full coverage (monthly): $190
  • Minimum coverage (monthly): $44

Why It’s the Best:
State Farm’s mobile app has the highest user ratings on both the Apple App Store (4.8) and Google Play Store (4.5). The app allows users to file and track claims, request roadside assistance, and manage policies seamlessly.

4. American Family – Best for Customer Satisfaction

  • Full coverage (annual): $2,131
  • Full coverage (monthly): $178
  • Minimum coverage (monthly): $56

Why It’s the Best:
American Family receives the fewest customer complaints relative to its size. It also ranks highly in J.D. Power’s 2024 U.S. Insurance Shopping Study for customer satisfaction.

5. USAA – Best for Military Members

  • Full coverage (annual): $1,452
  • Full coverage (monthly): $121
  • Minimum coverage (monthly): $31

Why It’s the Best:
Available exclusively to military members, veterans, and their families, USAA offers low premiums, excellent customer service, and discounts for military personnel who store their vehicles on base.


How NerdWallet Evaluated Car Insurance Companies

NerdWallet’s team assessed insurers based on the following factors:

  • Financial Strength (30%) – Ability to pay claims, assessed by AM Best, Moody’s, and Fitch.
  • Consumer Complaints (30%) – Complaints received by state insurance regulators.
  • Ease of Use (20%) – Availability of online tools, claims filing, and customer support.
  • Affordability (20%) – Discount availability and pricing competitiveness.

Honorable Mentions

If you’re looking for more options, here are other top-rated insurers that nearly made the list:

  • Progressive – Competitive rates and a user-friendly claims process.
  • Geico – Quick response times and budget-friendly options.
  • Liberty Mutual – Unique coverage options like lifetime repair guarantees.

How to Find the Best Car Insurance for You

Since insurance rates and coverage options vary by state, it’s best to compare multiple providers before making a decision. Here are some tips:

Compare Quotes – Rates differ based on your driving history and location.
Look for Discounts – Many insurers offer savings for safe driving, bundling, and loyalty.
Check Customer Reviews – Look at J.D. Power ratings and state complaint records.
Evaluate Coverage Options – Ensure your policy includes liability, collision, comprehensive, and uninsured motorist protection.


Final Thoughts

Whether you prioritize affordability, digital convenience, or customer satisfaction, these top car insurance companies of 2025 offer something for every driver. Before making a choice, compare personalized quotes to maximize your savings and coverage.

🚗 See how much you can save on car insurance by comparing quotes today!

Categorized in: